StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting - Admission/Application Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This project attempts to evaluate the relevance, practicality, and usefulness of the latest method of corporate accounting. Therefore, the writer will in detail describe the background of the accounting aspects in a light of the concept of throughput accounting…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting"

 Decline of Cost Accounting as a Management Accounting tool Managerial decision making is tangled with information generated by the accounting system employed by a company. Cost Accounting has long been the only method of generating data for Management Accounting purposes. It is almost a hundred years since Cost Accounting was first utilized by finance professionals to provide data that might be gainfully used in managerial decision making. It had been serving the purpose reasonably well as long as labor remained the primary variable factor of production. During a given period, profit could only be increased by extending the gap between revenue earned and cost (mostly labor cost) incurred. The situation however started changing rather quickly and labor is now no longer a variable factor of production. Instead it has become a part of fixed factory overhead in almost all manufacturing organizations. Thus the excessive emphasis on reducing labor cost and the practice of apportioning overhead expenses using direct labor hours as basis of apportionment will obviously give wrong results. Any management decision based on these figures might cause more harm than benefit the company. This led to the ushering of a new concept called the Activity Based Costing. The basis of this method was the fact that: labor is not the only driver of overhead expenses, especially in case of multi-product companies. This new method of accounting identified drivers that generated overhead expenses and apportioned these expenses in accordance with relative importance of those drivers. Activity Based Costing – Old Wine in a New Bottle? Though more rational from previous methods, Activity Based costing does not really represent a paradigm shift in generating meaningful data that would assist decision making. The similarities in approach between Activity Based Costing and conventional Cost Accounting are all too apparent for anybody to overlook those. Both the approaches consider ‘efficiency’ as the primary. They erroneously believe that local efficiency and optimization somehow adds up to overall efficiency and optimization. They consider management of cost rather than management of revenue to be more vital in realizing corporate goals. The total product cost is calculated by totaling direct material cost, direct labor cost and overhead cost, thus making all three constituents relevant during decision making. ABC is based on recognizing cost drivers and improve all links. These approaches do not attach any importance to constraints as being roadblocks to achieving corporate objectives. As a result, the most important factors that actually decide the efficiency and real profitability of an organization are not taken into account. Theory of Constraint It has been observed that in every organization there is at least one constraint that restricts the organization from reaching its corporate goals. The removal of these constraints automatically ensures an overall improvement in the performance of the entire organization. These constraints can be in the form of managerial constraints, capacity constraints, market constraints or even logistical constraints. Throughput accounting system lays a lot of emphasis on managers’ abilities to manage and exploit non-constraint resources in order to optimize and, if possible, release constraint resources to ensure higher organizational performance. Local optimization does not necessarily lead to overall optimization Accounting system views an entire organization as an arrangement of chains and flows of interlinked processes. ABC is based on recognizing cost drivers and improving “all” links. Throughput Accounting, on the other hand is based on the fact that: The company “system” is only as strong as its weakest link (Corbett, 1998). The duty of managers is to locate the weakest link in this chain and strengthen it as it might hamper the performance of the entire organization. It also assumes that local optimizations need not necessarily lead to overall corporate optimization. This concept though is rather difficult for divisional controllers and departmental managers to realize as they have a characteristically stunted view that begins and ends with their departments or divisions. An example might clarify the issue a bit more. Traditionally, output has been considered the unit for measuring activity levels and efficiency of an organization. Thus maximizing output, irrespective of whether it has a ready market or not, has been one of the holy grails of corporate organizations. This has been further bolstered by the practice of considering closing inventory as an asset. This leads to an erroneous approach of making the production, rather than demand as the overriding objective. This approach has led to many situations of huge unsold inventories, subsequent downsizing of labor and closure of factories. This is a clear example of how local optimization does not always enhance the overall efficiency. Instead, at times, it pulls down the entire organization. Basics of Throughput Accounting Most of the top managers of a company are interested in “level of revenue that the organization is able to generate”. This level of revenue is also sometimes refereed to as the attainable levels of throughput. Thus logically, throughput rather than output should be the most important issue for management to focus on. This new method of Management Accounting attempts to do precisely that. According to this method, Value should only be recognized on delivery (Corbett, 1998). Carrying on in the same vein, inventory including constituents like raw-material, WIP, finished goods, is considered to be the investment the company has made. This investment also includes the investment done in capital items such as buildings, plant and machinery. However, all expenses incurred in converting raw materials to finished goods are separately accounted for under the head operating expenses. This cost head includes direct and indirect labor cost, depreciation expense, interest payment, supplies and other operating expenses. So the emphasis clearly shifts from output to revenue. The objective of the management is in finding out ways and means of increasing throughput while reducing inventory and operating expenses. Five steps that the managers should take to identify and remove constraints are (Corbett, 1998): Recognize the constraints in the system Choose on a way to make use of the System's Constraint Focus all the additional resources to Constraint Exploitation. Acquire additional constrained resources. If a Constraint Has Been Broken in any of the previous steps, return to Step One The metrics of managerial efficiency also changes and become more meaningful with following measurements: a) Net Profit (NP) = Throughput - Operating Expense b) Return on Investment (ROI) = Net Profit / Inventory, and c) Inventory Turnover (IT) = Throughput / Inventory The concept of Net Profit actually utilizes the idea of marginal income while retaining the traditional emphasis on cost control and skillfully aligning it with the concept of revenue generation. The measure of Return on Investment uses inventory as a denominator. This shows that accumulating a large volume of inventory to achieve a predetermined production ratio level would not necessarily increase the throughput. Investments made with an eye on long term returns, the numerator shall also reflect the projected revenue inflows from these investments. But accountants have routinely voiced their doubts as to how effectively and realistically this can be done with regard to investments in Research and Development and Human Resources as these do not add value in the short run. The Inventory Turnover Ratio tries to estimate how quickly a given level of inventory can generate throughput. It also highlights the futility of accumulating large volumes of inventory unless such volumes can generate commensurate levels of throughput. Does it signal the ultimate demise of Traditional and Activity Based Costing? There has been a long standing and often vigorous debate in this regard. It can be seen that throughput accounting is essentially a short-term approach. This is clear from its rationalization that since direct labor and overhead cost cannot be changed during short-term; managing these costs would be impossible and not relevant. Proponents of Activity Based Costing however believe that the key to gain competitive advantage in the long run is providing superior product at the most efficient cost as compared to competitors. Thus managing the cost in the long run is equally important in gaining competitiveness. In spite of its apparent short term emphasis, throughput system of accounting however introduces the important concept of constraints. These constraints can in practice curtail the ability of an organization to achieve corporate goals. Any accounting system that does not take into account these constraints cannot properly portray the functioning of an organization. This might lead to management taking wrong and potentially debilitating decisions that may affect long term sustainability of an organization. Considering these factors it seems that the best option for an organization would be to embrace Activity Based Costing as a long term perspective while retaining Throughput Accounting as a short term measure. A company with constraints in its system shall choose Throughput Accounting. If however, managers feel that local efficiencies will lead to a good choice, then they should go for ABC. References Corbett, Thomas.(1998). Throughput Accounting. Great Barrington, MA: North River Press. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting Admission/Application Essay”, n.d.)
Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting Admission/Application Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1555422-throughput-accounting-see-details-below
(Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting Admission/Application Essay)
Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting Admission/Application Essay. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1555422-throughput-accounting-see-details-below.
“Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting Admission/Application Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1555422-throughput-accounting-see-details-below.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Throughput Accounting: A Critique of This New Method of Accounting

Management Accounting - Johnson and Kaplans Relevance Lost

Roslender and Hart (2003) noted that in the present business environment, accounting largely focuses on the preparation of accounting reports and less on bookkeeping, which has been reduced to fairly a routine process because of the increased computerization and introduction of more effective systems of internal control.... A Discussion on Johnson and Kaplan's Relevance Lost Abstract This present paper is a research paper that looks at the criticisms, which were made by Johnson and Kaplan (1987) in regards to management accounting/ control systems....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Accounting Research

It also presents the aspects of accounting research that have been helpful in real market scenarios.... Baker suggests that "throughout society, the influence of accounting permeates the fundamental issues concerning wealth distribution, social justice, political ideology and environmental degradation.... The impact of the research in the field of accounting theory has however been little on the world.... There seem to be several views and dimensions of accounting research that lack practicability and relevance when it comes to practical world....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Standard Costing Methods

The paper 'Standard Costing Methods' presents cost accounting which dates back to the period of the industrial revolution.... hellip; Although the surviving business records of 25 sizeable British firms serve as evidence for the statement that British entrepreneurs used standard costing methods even in the pre-industrial period 1760-1850, it is still considered that cost accounting began to attract the wide interest of industrialists only after 1880.... Originally, cost accounting systems were mainly concerned with variable costs, such as labor and raw materials expenditures....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Analysis of the New CIO

Due to the fact that has briefly been leveraged in question 1, this author can recognize that whether one considers the way that communications take place throughout an organization, the method that payments are ultimately disbursed, the means by which information systems are kept up to date, the programs that drive the economic and accounting systems that ultimately derive the bulk of the organization's profits, or the maintenance and sustainment of the infrastructure that records timely and extraordinarily important historical data, IT forms the backbone and transit system through which each of these processes run....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Accounting for Strategy and Management Control - Korpi & Ala-Risku

hellip; The first function of accounting is process-oriented, a matter of form, while the second is value-oriented, a matter of substance.... This paper "accounting for Strategy and Management Control - Korpi & Ala-Risku" focuses on the fact that according to Marx's argument in Capital, accounting has two essential functions - that of recognition of the economic process and the function of mediating the metamorphosis of economic value.... he article to be critiqued is “Life cycle costing: a review of published case studies,” which deals with life-cycle costing as a method used in managerial accounting....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Is Accounting the Most Effective Means to Achieve Company's Accountability

Moreover, the role of accounting in accountability has been analyzed and finally, the limitations of accounting have been discussed.... The paper “Is accounting the Most Effective Means to Achieve Company's Accountability?... rdquo; proves that accounting - financial statements and reporting - is a more effective tool to ensure business's accountability compared with other mechanisms - corporate governance and efficient HRM systems....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Environment Management and Sustainable Development When Constructing in a Seismic Zone

"Environment Management and Sustainable Development When Constructing in a Seismic Zone" paper covers the ways of minimizing the consumption of natural resources in the environment as well as energy during the construction phase and throughout the life of the project in a seismic environment.... hellip; For many years, the environment has been a thorny issue, especially when it comes to the construction of large institutional structures in a seismic environment....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework

Freud's Psychoanalytic Theory

Vivian proved to have a method of centering Edward and encompass him looking at living in a more liberated and revitalized way.... REUD'S PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORYOne of the central criticisms of nearly all theories of character is that they have intricacy accounting for the absurd, less conventional patterns of human philosophy and performance....
3 Pages (750 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us