StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
An author of the current essay "Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System" will shed light on the organization of certain sanction strategies within the justice system. Furthermore, the writer evaluates the effectiveness of reducing crime after implementation of such sanctions…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.7% of users find it useful
Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System"

a) Provided the loopholes in the implementation are prevented, diversion programmes can necessarily be designed in a way in which they provide reasonable sanction for the action that led to potential system involvement. But one has to be very cautious in doing this because, “neither diversion nor deinstitutionalization programmes” have found much success yet (Klein, 1979, p.146). But there has always been a very strong theoretical base for its implementation of diversion programmes and also a social and political demand for it (Klein, 1979, p.147). (b) An optimal sanctioning strategy for diversion programme must not be totally averse to the use of “usual practices” and “various components of the justice system” (Klein, 1979, p.152). There should be means to bring back the concerned person into formal system in case of failure of the treatment (Klein, 1979, p.152). Thirdly, the diversion should not lapse into non-treatment (Klein, 1979, p.152). Utmost care has to be taken in selecting the clients because it has to be ensured that they are apt for diversion programmes (Klien, 1979, p.160). To place the client in a separate locality other than directly inside the community will be a wiser option because it has been proven that there is no less stitgmatization involved in a community situation (Klein, 1979, p.181). The key concept of an optimal sanctioning strategy must be “diversion without referral, diversion away from but not to.

” (Klein, 1979, p.183). Thus diversion has to become “a positive extension of the existing juvenile justice system” (Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli, 1984, p.305). (c) In the diversion programme carried out in Adams County, Colorado, the objective was to “reduce court caseloads; lower recidivism rates; not lower the net of social control; and, lend itself to rigorous evaluation” (Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli, 1984, p.306). Under the project, first or second time offenders were diverted to enable courts to concentrate on multiple offenders, follow up programmes were implemented, social control was imparted through a multidisciplinary team and rigorous evaluation was carried out (Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli, 1984, p.307). The project was a partial success but recidivism was found to be lowered (Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli, 1984, p.320). Ezell had studied a juvenile arbitration programme and had shown it to be even less effective as a diversion programme than the one studied by Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli (Ezell, 1989; Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli, 1984).

In Ezell’s case study, after the arbitration programme started, more number of youth were sent to court (Ezell, 1989, p.364). The operation of the local juvenile justice system had changed in a positive way but the diversion was occurring only within the system which was actually widening its net to include more youth under it (Ezell, 1989, p.364). Thus the model discussed by Pogrebin, Poole and Regoli (1984) has a better chance to become socially relevant. 2. (a) The transfer has not reduced crime rates (Fagan, 2008, p.81). It has also been observed that “juveniles who have been tried as adults are no less likely to re-offend than their counterparts who have been tried as juveniles” (Fagan, 2008, p.81). Fagan is of the opinion that the juvenile transfer to adult systems exposes them to “harsh and sometimes toxic forms of punishment …that… have the perverse effect of increasing criminal activity” (2008, p.83). But the transfers have helped the juvenile courts to maintain their “legitimacy by removing hard cases” that challenged their right to show leniency to the juveniles (Fagan, 2008, p.82). As the transfer decision is taken in a case by case manner, the individual consideration of judges have a role to play and this has given rise to some alarming racist decisions as well (Fagan, 2008, p.96) (b) The risks/benefits are more apparent in certain forms of transfer.

Particularly when the legislators and prosecutors are entrusted with decisions, the risks are present in a greater degree (Fagan, 2008, p.88). When age and offense thresholds become the criteria, the risks are lessened but when judicial discretion is the criterion, there can always be the risk of subjective bias (Fagan, 2008, p.86). The blended sentencing is yet another form of transfer which is risky rather than beneficial to the juvenile offenders (Fagan, 2008, p.90). References Ezell, M. (1989) Juvenile arbitration: net widening and other unintended consequences, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, Vol.

26, 358-377. Fagan, J. (Fall 2008) Juvenile crime and criminal justice: resolving border disputes, The Future of Children, Vol.18, No.2, 81-118. Klein, M.W. (1979) Deinstitutionalisation and diversion of juvenile offenders: a litany of impediments, Crime and Justice, Vol.1, 145-201. Pogrebin, M.R., Poole, E.D. and Regoli, R.M. (1984) Constructing and implementing a model juvenile diversion programme, Youth Society, Vol.15, 305-324.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System Essay”, n.d.)
Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1405893-essay
(Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System Essay)
Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1405893-essay.
“Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1405893-essay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Juvenile Crime Policies: The Need for Sanction System

Juvenile Offenders and Re-offending Rates

Such system, inspired by the American system of policing, punishing and shaming juvenile offenders has been applied in the UK ever since the 1990's.... 0 In Australia, a mild system, re – offending rates are visibly lower for non – custodial... 6 Such an approach by judges and communities changes the impact of governmental policies and decisions.... crime in most countries is seen as misbehaviour that needs to be punished....
5 Pages (1250 words) Literature review

Juvenile and Adult Courts

The juvenile justice system and the adult criminal justice system are two dissimilar systems of justice and they are founded on different philosophies, although both the systems have close resemblance in many states currently.... By and large, the basic distinction between the two systems is that the juvenile justice system mainly focuses on the rehabilitation of juvenile offenders whereas the adult criminal justice system emphasizes the punishment of criminals....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Case Perspective in Juvenile Justice System

Data compiled by the National Centre for Juvenile Justice and Office for Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention shows that “the peak hours for violent juvenile crime are between 3.... "Case Perspective in Juvenile Justice system" paper states that comprehensive intervention programs should be used to fostering cooperation among families, schools, and communities to interact with child offenders who are prone to commit serious and violent crimes.... Children in the USA are arrested, under the provisions of the “Juvenile Justice system,” on suspicion of violating criminal laws for frequent truancy, running away from home, violating curfew, possession of alcohol, possession of marijuana, and shoplifting....
8 Pages (2000 words) Coursework

What mitigating factors contribute to juveniles being charged as adults

Since people… ow a certain age group cannot be punished according to adult laws and cannot be placed in adult prisons, they are placed in juvenile delinquent prisons or are subjected to a shorter prison term than adults over the age of eighteen who are fully charged and accountable for their 15-16).... They usually confront punishments, such as community service, attendance of rehabilitation centers, or sent to juvenile delinquent prisons for a short period....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Juvenile Executions

This division helped in promote alternative sentencing and program for juvenile crime.... This research proposal "Juvenile Executions" gives an overview of the juvenile execution system and how it came into effect.... hellip; The whole idea of the juvenile execution system is not a good form of punishment and many are now against it.... Many organizations are now fighting for the abolishment of the juvenile system entirely and they are hoping that they would succeed....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Proposal

The Juvenile Justice System

From the paper "The Juvenile Justice system" it is clear that examining the ways in which the juvenile court can be improved, it has been found that an optimal system of integrating both juvenile and adult courts would have the most successful outcomes.... hellip; The main way in which the juvenile court can be improved is to allow the segregation of only minor juvenile offenders under the juvenile court system.... The adult criminal justice system consists of the laws, procedures, professionals, authorities and institutions which are applicable to witnesses and victims and to adults accused of, alleged to have, or recognized to have committed a criminal offence (United Nations Office: 1, 54)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Juvenile Delinquencies in the Contemporary World

Community policing is another effective approach to curbing juvenile crime; residents are trained on how to identify suspicious activities, and thereafter reported to the police.... Nevertheless, effective juvenile justice and the policing system are necessary to curb juvenile delinquencies.... The juvenile justice system in the United States involves children below the age of 18 years; in Ohio, each county has a juvenile court, which tries juvenile offenders....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Should Juveniles Be Treated as Adults in Violent Crimes

The perception of the public in the 1980s was that juvenile crime was on increase because of the leniency of the juvenile system.... This paper concerns the inefficacy of the US juvenile justice system....  … Throughout the past two decades, in spite of the considerable declines in adolescence delinquent rates, the viewpoint of the public on youth violence has motivated the prevalent support for elimination of the juvenile court system as well as the implementation of more stringent crime legislation in the country....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us