StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

If Posion Gas Can Go, Why not Nukes By James Carroll - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author presents a question in his title, that is answered in the great article. The rhetorical question actually emphasizes that banning nuclear weapon is indeed, very difficult. Besides, it also…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
If Posion Gas Can Go, Why not Nukes By James Carroll
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "If Posion Gas Can Go, Why not Nukes By James Carroll"

CC2 Sujen R. Croman Critical Analysis Minglei Chen If Poison Gas Can Go, Why Not Nukes? By James Carroll: This paper evaluates the argument made by James Carroll in his article. The author presents a question in his title, that is answered in the great article. The rhetorical question actually emphasizes that banning nuclear weapon is indeed, very difficult. Besides, it also supports the main idea that says that nuclear abolition is nearly impossible to achieve. The author presented his opinion in the first paragraph, and later made use of relevant examples to support his argument.

In the second paragraph, he expresses that many people have tried to abandon chemical weapons in early twentieth century, yet they could not succeed in their attempt. Same patterns prevail today and it is just as difficult to ban the use of nuclear weapons as it was in the past.In the third paragraph, the author says that people hold different opinions on whether chemical weapons should be banned or not. However, the contradiction is only apparent. Actually, no one would keep from using chemical weapons in a war.

In the past, the chemical weapon has proved very powerful. Therefore many countries acquired it and used it as required. However, because of the massive destruction to life and property as a result of its use, people have started to consider banning chemical weapon. In the fourth paragraph, the author expresses that there has been peace for a while since the peoples concern about aborting the use of chemical weapons, and no or very little use of chemical weapons has been made. After the World War I, the movement to ban chemical weapon resumed.

The poison gas was outlawed by the Geneva Convention. That was similar to banning chemical weapon. However, in the World War II, most countries used chemical weapon once again. In the fifth paragraph, the author highlights how the use of nuclear weapon widened considerably after the World War II. Technologically advanced countries began to possess their own bombs. The mushroom cloud became a real nightmare. Consequently, no one used chemical weapon anymore, as all proceeded to make nuclear weapon and the situation worsened further.

The author puts forward an excellent example to explain why it is nearly impossible to abandon nuclear weapon today, just like it was to relinquish chemical weapon in the past. He has presented a lot of facts and statistics to make the whole argument valid through reliable data. The author has maintained a moderate tone throughout the article. He narrates a story in which he tried to present the chemical weapon as an example. With the passage of time, people developed different attitudes towards poison gas.

Initially, no one accepted to ban it. After the World War I, they made significant effort to ban the chemical weapon. However, as the new generation weapon came out, use of chemical weapon practically declined to extinguishment. In the language part, the author expresses how horrible the chemical weapon has been a lot of times. Obviously, he wants to convey that it is harmful. But people just could not help using it. In this respect, there is a little satire in his essay. As for the persona, I have found the author objective.

He puts forward so many evidences to prove that abandoning the use of chemical and nuclear weapon is in the best interest of mankind. The author has made a lot of effort to support his assertion. The evidence is reliable as the history he refers to is exactly as he has presented it. The whole article is clearly organized and logical. Every paragraph has its own point and contributes to the development of the complete argument. The language is easy for the readers to understand. The author has made use of emotional language to explain how people have developed fear for the weapons.

The author also offers expertise in this article. However, the argument is totally biased towards justifying the authors opinion. Therefore, I feel it shows only one side of the picture.Bibliography:Carroll, James. “If Poison Gas Can Go, Why Not Nukes?” The Boston Globe. 23 June 2008. Web. 31 Oct. 2010. .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“If Posion Gas Can Go, Why not Nukes By James Carroll Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1571916-if-posion-gas-can-go-why-not-nukes-by-james-carroll
(If Posion Gas Can Go, Why Not Nukes By James Carroll Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1571916-if-posion-gas-can-go-why-not-nukes-by-james-carroll.
“If Posion Gas Can Go, Why Not Nukes By James Carroll Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1571916-if-posion-gas-can-go-why-not-nukes-by-james-carroll.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF If Posion Gas Can Go, Why not Nukes By James Carroll

How Carroll's Alice Deconstructs the Victorian Notions of Femininity

This paper "How carroll's Alice Deconstructs the Victorian Notions of Femininity" discusses carroll's Alice that deconstructs the Victorian notions of femininity and female coming of age in several ways.... And though some feminist critics like Nina Auerbach have argued that Alice is a subversive feminist heroine, in fact, carroll's youthful protagonist seems to be nothing more or less than an ordinary Victorian girl – and rather than limiting the possibilities of the narrative, this realization expands them, allowing us to understand Alice as a creature of her own era, so that she – more than the Wonderland she traverses – becomes the vehicle of carroll's Victorian satire....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Business Ethics and Social Responsibility at Nike

We know what we want to achieve and we go for it 100 per cent of the time” (Yu).... The company was founded in 1971, when the cofounder placed a piece of rubber into a kitchen waffle iron (Kimmel, Weygandt and Kieso 549).... Nike derives its name from Greek mythology.... The winged goddess of victory was called Nike… Nike has gained fame and repute over the period of time, and is an established multinational brand that deals with the production of footwear and clothing....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Lewis Carroll's Photographs

hellip; According to the study, Lewis carroll took his famous photographs in this era and, in order to market his literary works, sought to identify misconceptions long held by adults concerning children.... Lewis carroll sought to show children as adult shadows, the children's identity as being shadowed by the adults, as well as the shadows that the children cast.... Therefore, this paper will seek to show how Lewis carroll used children in his photographs to show their innocence and the misconceptions that adults oftentimes had about them....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Dose makes the poison

Moreover, also focus on how the toxic and deadly effects of the chemicals can be avoided is also of importance.... It is vital to understand what is toxic in our environment and can lead to adverse effects.... A toxic substance is a substance that can be poisonous or cause health effects.... Toxicity of a substance is not measured on the basis of its severity of effects; it can strike a single cell, a group of cells, an organ or the whole body....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

James Doolittle in Aviation

He married in 1917 and was married for 70 years with two sons who also followed in their father's footsteps and became military aviators (Doolittle and carroll 25).... Work CitedDoolittle, James and carroll Glines.... The essay "james Doolittle in Aviation" focuses on Doolittle's passion in airplanes and this drove him to enlist in the military.... james Doolittle in AviationDoolittle was born in Alameda, California in December of 1896 but spent his youth in Alaska but later came back to Los Angeles to attend school....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Children's literature - Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll Short story

Undoubtedly one of the shy Mathematical teachers at Oxford, Lewis carroll represented a body that was, for many people, unable to produce a long sentence without stammering, let alone publish one of the greatest children's literature of all times.... Howbeit, in face of all… cations and impossibilities, Lewis carroll possessed an imaginative and immensely creative mind, which was the sole reason for the production of Alice's Adventure in Wonderland. This story is about a girl Alice (based on the author's child friend Alice Liddell) who is shown to be following a white rabbit to a hole, which is a doorway to the wonderland where Alice meets with different creatures and experiences a completely new realm in her life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Alice in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll

This review "Alice in Wonderland by Lewis carroll" discusses children are and how they can be.... She considers being a “telescope” because “so many out-of-the-way things had happened lately that Alice had begun to think that very few things indeed were really impossible” (carroll, 1865, p.... rdquo; (carroll, 1865, p.... While society does not criticize itself for its mistakes, carroll (1865) shows how children are better off because of their sense of self-responsibility....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Boston 2024 Olympic Games

Bids can be sent to the IOC between January 15, 2015, and September 15, 2015 (Swidey, 2015).... In the following paper “Boston 2024 Olympic Games” the author looks at the International Olympic Committee (IOC), an international non-profit, non-governmental organization based in Switzerland, which organizes the Olympic Games every four years....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us