StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The dominant approach in international relations theory for virtually the past two millennia, from Thucydides to Machiavelli to Morgenthau, has been Realism, also known as Political Realism. Realists come in many stripes. Most notably, they divide between Classical Realists and Contemporary Structural Realists or Non-realists…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.6% of users find it useful
Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations"

Download file to see previous pages

The state, for Realism, is a power-maximizer in a self-help environment where no one can be trusted and violence is endemic. Non-Realist IR theory is invariably also anti-Realist. It never ignores Realism, but always incorporates a critique of that paradigm to position itself intellectually. This is because Realism is about the state. Since we cannot evade the state, which is everywhere and all around us and the centre-piece of our political cosmology, neither can IR theory evade Realism. Empirical "tests" may show that certain events in the world are (not in) consistent with the hard core of a realist research program.

But that does not provide support in any strong sense of that term for choosing realism over some competing paradigm. Many events that are explained by one realist theory are also inconsistent with at least one other no less authentic realist theory. For instance, if balancing and bandwagoning exhaust the possible aligning bahaviours of states, as Waltz (1979) suggests they do, and if good realist theories predict each, as they do, then any piece of evidence simultaneously confirm and contradicts "realism".

Labs provide an extreme example of the perspective when he presents offensive (rather than defensive) realism as "the best realist theory available to go forward and do battle with competing approaches to international relations" (1997, p. 48). Neither, however, will get realist very far in such a battle. Sovereignty is the primary concept of realism. It is taken as given that states enjoy unchallenged jurisdiction within their own boundaries. Realists make little attempt to theorize the impact a state's relationship with its civil society has upon its relations with other states.

Waltz expresses this simplistic view when he writes that 'students of international politics will do well to concentrate on separate theories of internal and external politics until someone figures out a way to unite them (Rosenberg 1994, p. 5). Waltz is able to argue this because of his view of how the states sys operates. Waltz (1979) rejects explanations of international conflict which stress flaws in human nature. Rather it is the structure of the international system that creates tension between states: in the absence of a higher authority, states compete with each other to ensure their security.

This may trigger an arms race, perhaps leading to full-scale war. This structure will determine a state's foreign policy, regardless of its internal political arrangements or the nature of the dominant belief system within civil society. The strength of realism is that it highlights the irrationalities that underpin the login of a world divided into states. The conflicts between states, which are well documented by history, and which often transcend apparent commonalities of 'race' or ideology, present compelling evidence in support of the realist argument.

It is increasingly clear, however, the realism's assumptions are inadequate to the task of explaining the nature of contemporary world politics. The problems of mainstream international relations theory lie mainly in its understanding of state sovereignty and security. Realists and non-realists are tuned to account for different dimensions of international relations. As realist theories are especially well-suited to explain certain

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/politics/1501849-realist-and-neo-realist-international-relations
(Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations Essay)
https://studentshare.org/politics/1501849-realist-and-neo-realist-international-relations.
“Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/politics/1501849-realist-and-neo-realist-international-relations.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Realist and Neo-Realist International Relations

In what ways is Neo-realism similar to traditional Realism

The essay will present an underlying understanding of the major similarities between traditional realism and neo-realism… Realism can be regarded as the most well established theoretical perspective in the arena of international politics and international relations.... Realism has had dominance in international relations to the extent that scholars forget it is one of the perspectives among many.... At this time, realists developed arguments that explained the debates on power relations, the balance of power, as well as international politics....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Realism, Neo-realism, Marxist Theories, Bipolarity, Hyperglobalism as Political Philosophies

Neo-realism ignores the classical realism concept to explain international politics but develops a theory that favors structural constraints on agent's strategies and motivation.... It highlights that international disorder is the main cause of disturbance in global politics....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Classical Realism and Liberal Internationalism

This can be attributed to the fact that international relations are still young in its field and feels the need to justify itself intellectually.... I will rationally argue that classical realists' works such as Morgenthau and Thucydides remain foundational texts for international relation scholars and are cited more frequently than their counterparts in the disciplines of social sciences....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The theory to the Study of International Relations

hellip; This paper takes a look at the critical theory to the study if international relations with emphasis on Realism, Liberalism, Marxism, and Neo-Marxism.... international relations is the study of the relations in diplomacy and diplomatic history, international law, organizations, finance, economics, commerce, and communication among others.... It is worthwhile to take a look at the above definitions and examine whether international relations truly reflect the emotions and desires of the people of the erstwhile Soviet-bloc....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Realism as One of the Concepts That Have Evoked a Wide Range of Controversy

In the international relations theory, there has evolved a big controversy on which concept best describes how nations relate and how conflict among international states can be resolved.... olitical realism has three important tenets that apply within the international relations theory.... First, realism describes the concept of 'statism' and describes states as the major role players in international politics.... Unlike the liberalism theories that consider the role of non-states sectors within international politics, realism theory is state-centric....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Neorealism and Classical Realism

The study is based on the re-examination of Kenneth Waltz and Hans Morgenthau's Theories on Of international relations.... From a realist's perspective, the state or the country is a principle unit and actor in majority of the international affairs.... These countries gain the most leverage on the international platform.... These act as the realist's analytical tools....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Anarchy and Power

This case study "Anarchy and Power" addresses briefly the different connotations of the notion of anarchy in accordance with its relation to realist and liberal international relations theories.... It offers a comprehensive study on all the ideas surrounding the political philosophy of anarchy while precisely reviewing the theories of international relations.... his paper addresses briefly the different connotations of the notion of anarchy in accordance with its relation to realist and liberal international relations theories....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

The Difference Between the Classical and Neo Realistic Approach

  Although, it is only over 2500 years since the science of international relations became the academic subject and the classical realists stepped in this sphere.... In magnum opus from 1948, Politics Among Nations, Morgenthau studied in a critical way the political realism that was the leading theory in the sphere of international relations for more than several decades.... n the international relations sphere, scientists consider the current state of things to be the dominant element in IR....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us