StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper will begin with the statement that in his article entitled “The Speaker of the Prelude,” author Mark Reed argues that the seemingly piecemeal compilation of William Wordsworth’s lengthy poem The Prelude is an integral aspect of the work. …
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.8% of users find it useful
William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed"

Argument Analysis – Mark Reed In his article en d “The Speaker of the Prelude,” Mark Reed argues that the seemingly piecemeal compilation of William Wordsworth’s lengthy poem The Prelude is an integral aspect of the work. Throughout the article, Reed works to prove that this sporadic approach demonstrates through structure the growth and change that Wordsworth is attempting to describe in the action. The poem has long been a source of intense study by scholars because of its unsure status as a stand-alone piece or as a portion of a larger and uncompleted whole. Not only is it among the longest poems ever written, consisting of approximately 13 books (depending on the edition being used – later revised versions reached 14 books), The Prelude was also intended to serve as an introduction to a greater work Wordsworth envisioned. Throughout the work, Wordsworth changes tone, voice, tense and subject frequently, making any attempts to treat the poem as a work in and of itself nearly impossible. However, Reed, through his argument, attempts to show that this changeful nature is the unifying factor by bringing attention to the transient nature of life itself. Reed begins this argument by illustrating the various aspects of the poem that have prevented earlier scholars from attempting to develop an understanding of the work as a whole, illustrating the dissecting nature of the initial premises upon which these attempts were based. One approach taken is based on the fact that the work is essentially an autobiography of the artist and therefore follows his life story as Wordsworth remembered it rather than developing along a straightforward line of action. The extended period of time through which the poem was written is another argument scholars have used to prevent them from attempting to approach the work as a free-standing construction. The poem’s heavy revisions and obvious intention to be connected to a longer piece have further complicated the issue while the frequent shifts of character and tone indicate a need for further explanation lying outside the text. Acknowledging that all of these objections are valid to some extent, Reed indicates that while other approaches to the poem are helpful to developing an understanding of Wordsworth’s thoughts, an attempt to understand the poem as an artistic whole is necessary to truly understand Wordworth’s intentions. With this in mind, Reed justifies the importance of treating the poem as an artistic whole on the concepts that were linked to the poem by Wordsworth himself. Reed points out that both Wordsworth and his sister referred to The Prelude as a poem, complete and whole in itself, long before it was ever published and prior to some of the extensive revisions Wordsworth made in later years. This, he says, indicates more than anything that the poem was intended to be understood as an artistic work of its own rather than dependent upon a secondary source. Reed, illustrating the fastidiousness of Wordsworth regarding his art, insists Wordsworth would not have referred to The Prelude as complete, instead, he would have indicated the work as ‘started’, ‘begun’ or in some other stage of creation, appellation or development. Making a strong case on this point, Reed insists that an understanding of the poet’s intentions must necessarily take into account the artist’s impressions regarding the work, meaning that the work must be considered as a whole because Wordsworth considered it a whole. Recognizing that the changes in tone and stance present the greatest challenge to scholars attempting to read the poem as an artistic whole rather than a segment of a greater work, Reed concentrated on developing a plausible hypothesis regarding the reason Wordsworth included these seemingly out of place comments, “namely, his frequently interjected expressions of what appear to be the personal emotions or circumstances of the literal William Wordsworth either only shortly before or immediately in the act of writing: Such expressions, one might readily suppose, could not individually have made very specific parts of the poet’s settled formal intentions or ‘first conception.’” (279). These include personal messages to other writers, statements regarding Wordsworth’s own self-doubts and struggles as he wrote the work, and passing distractions that interrupt or prevent him from working for stretches of time. Rather than being examples of a lack of control on Wordsworth’s part or a complete inattentiveness to the art he was practicing, Reed argues that these comments are essential to understanding Wordsworth’s primary purpose in writing the poem, that of demonstrating the growth and development of a mature poetic mind. While the changes in character and tone have often been pointed to as evidence that Wordsworth was not conforming to the elements of poetry, Reed indicates that these seeming digressions into the present are instead Wordsworth’s attempts to demonstrate the full development of the poet’s mind, as he understood it. “Consciousness of, and efforts to draw attention to, the manifold ranges of not primarily aesthetic truths that may lie behind, and in, one’s art hardly in themselves imply indifference to its forms and techniques. The baldness that characterizes some of the Lyrical Ballads is the consequence not of carelessness but of an artistic ‘plan’ or ‘experiment.’ It was a man extremely concerned about the techniques by which he spoke to men” (277). Removing these seeming digressions and asides would remove the knowledge of hindsight and eliminate the possibility of illustrating the importance of various events and conclusions that would shape later actions and thoughts, thus reducing the understanding of the poetic mind’s true development. This final argument is further supported by a deep analysis of Book VI in which Reed illustrates that the thoughts of the literal Wordsworth are necessary to illustrate the deepened understanding and insight gained by the poet as he reflects upon the impressions and emotions felt during the actions described. In this passage of the poem, Wordsworth is describing his walking tour of Europe and the disillusionment he experiences while crossing the Alps. The commentary of the poet as he is writing become an expression of how the poet is created because it expresses his current abilities to comprehend his art and the lessons he learned as a younger man. “Just as Imagination, or its activity in the mature mind of man as represented by the speaker, apprehends the particulars of the speaker’s past personal experience within a creative vision, so the vocalization of what seem present or nearly present specifically personal facts or attitudes of the speaker is a continued expression of the ability of the imaginative mind to comprehend creatively these sorts of realities. To sum up, the Prelude is a poem that both describes the growth of Imagination and demonstrates the Imagination as a living and present mode of vision; the second function is realized not only through the creative action of the Imagination as it organizes the speaker’s past experience, including minute details, but also through its creative action as it expresses the nature of his present being, including its minute details” (280-281). Through his analysis, Reed demonstrates the importance of the literal Wordsworth to the understanding of the text as a whole. “Three main types of subject matter are synthesized: the physical realities of the original scene and action, the stretching of the overwhelmed responses of the travelers toward levels of insight beyond their present capacities, and the all-inclusive unifying force of the mature Imagination as it reveals itself in the poetic totality of the words and lines” (286). Removing one aspect of this presentation, such as the seemingly present comments of the writer as he is writing, removes this innate understanding of the growth process of the poetic mind and reduces the message of the poem as a whole. Works Cited Reed, Mark. “The Speaker of the Prelude.” Bicentenary Wordsworth Studies: In Memory of John Allen Finch. Jonathon Wordsworth (Ed.). 1970. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed Article - 1”, n.d.)
William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed Article - 1. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1540472-argument-analysis-on-a-critics-essay-on-the-prelude
(William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed Article - 1)
William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed Article - 1. https://studentshare.org/literature/1540472-argument-analysis-on-a-critics-essay-on-the-prelude.
“William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed Article - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1540472-argument-analysis-on-a-critics-essay-on-the-prelude.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF William Wordsworths Poem in The Speaker of the Prelude by Mark Reed

Mont Blanc by Percy Shelly and Prelude by William Wordsworth

Wordsworth's longest poem is 'the prelude' which is an autobiographical or a philosophical poem and could be called as the magnum opus of his works.... This essay would compare and contrast the ways in which nature is described in Shelly's famous poem 'Mont Blanc' and Wordsworth's 'prelude'.... Through his poem, he wants to bridge the gap between the understandings of the human mind and the power of the nature.... Within the poem is a contrast seen in the attributes of nature....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Tintern Abbey by William Wordsworth

In one of his deepest expressions, found in lines 55-57 of the poem, he speaks to the Wye Valley as though it is more than just a place for respite from modern life; his language is that of a man to his lover.... william Wordsworth uses nature as a key relational element for life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

How Applicable Is This to the Work of Wordsworth

hellip; The author states that considered one of William Wordsworth's most important poems, the prelude occupied the poet throughout his life.... the prelude is autobiographical and essential to understanding Wordsworth' life and poetry.... the prelude's fourteen books collect Wordsworth's meditations on his life, his poetic vocation, and its evolution, and some historic critics claim it contains the poet's thoughts on his contemporary political context, such as his views on the French Revolution....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Comparison analysis of poems To the Daisy and The Stolen Boat by William Wordsworth

In the first poem, the poet begins by praising the flower 'daisy' because this flower is often used to signify death.... This essay analyses two poems written by W.... ordsworth.... "The Stolen Boat' concentrates on the 'Being' that dwells within Nature.... hellip; There are two contradictory elements within the same object of nature....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

William Wordsworth

William spent five years writing an autobiographical poem.... It was through this that his famous Prospectus became known, which detailed the structure and intent of the poem contained in the volume.... william was the second of five children.... His sister, Dorothy, was a poet and diarist, and was very close with william.... She became one of… william had an older brother and two younger brothers.... william and his siblings had no relationship with their father. Even though william's father was hardly present, it was he who taught william poetry....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Daffodils by William Wordsworth

This essay declares that one of the treasured poem in the history, “Daffodils” also known by the title “I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud” was written in 1804 by William Wordsworth.... nbsp;… As the discussion highlights, William Wordsworth known for his love for nature composed the poem in a very simple and remarkable manner.... The poem was published in 1815 in “Collected Poems” compromising of four stanzas....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Societys Decline in Blake and Wordsworth

The signs of decay and desperation are seen in every face encountered as the speaker walks down what is presumed to be an average London street.... This is reinforced in the second stanza as the speaker says, “In every cry of every man, / In every infant's cry of fear, / In every voice, in every ban, / The mind-forged manacles I hear” (4-8).... Although he is describing physical situations in lines 3-4: “A mark in every face I meet / Marks of weakness, marks of woe”, he makes it clear that he is also discussing the state of the souls of people he meets....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Romanticism of I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud by William Wordsworth

The goal of the current assignment is to explore the central themes brought up in the poem "I Wandered Lonely as a Cloud" written by William Wordsworth.... Additionally, the writer will conduct a reflective analysis of literary elements and images depicted in the poem.... This way, the poem has a unique emotional appeal, a prerequisite in romanticism (Wordsworth & Suomalainen, 2005).... Romanticism requires a personal touch with the lyrics in a poem....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us